Tilleys Tavern

Nestled in the heart of Mt Olive, Illinois, Tilleys Tavern offers an inviting bar & grill experience that perfectly blends classic small-town charm with bold, satisfying flavors. This local gem prides itself on delivering hearty, comfort-driven dishes that keep patrons coming back time and again.

From the moment you step inside the warm, casually decorated space, you get a genuine sense of community and friendliness—an atmosphere where good food and good company naturally coincide. Whether you’re settling in for a relaxed dinner or grabbing a bite after a long day, Tilleys Tavern’s menu is filled with mouthwatering options that appeal to a variety of tastes.

Signature dishes like the Hamburger Horseshoe and Steak Horseshoe deliver a hearty embrace of Midwestern culinary tradition, stacked high with generous portions of savory meat atop crispy fries smothered in rich cheese sauce. For wing enthusiasts, the Sweet Garlic Parm Wings offer a unique balance of sweet and savory, perfectly complementing the classic buffalo wings if you’re craving a little heat.

Burger lovers will find their haven here with crowd favorites such as the classic Cheese Burger, the earthy and melty Mushroom Swiss Burger, or the indulgent Bacon Cheese Burger. For those seeking something bolder, specialty creations like the spicy Jalapeno Burger, the flavor-packed Randy Burger, or the tangy Western Burger provide exciting twists. Vegetarians aren’t left out either, with satisfying options like the Portobello Burger and crispy Portobello Mushroom Fingers.

The side dishes complement the mains perfectly, from crisp French Fries and seasoned variants to a fresh Side Salad and indulgent Cheese Sauce. And if you’re in the mood to finish on a sweet note, the Pumpkin Praline Cheesecake with Caramel Topping is a decadent treat that lingers on your palate.

Beyond the generous, flavorful fare, Tilleys Tavern carries a robust selection of beverages, including well-crafted cocktails and an impressive array of whiskies, highlighted by choices like Jameson Irish Whiskey and rich bourbon offerings. This makes it an ideal spot not only for dinner but for unwinding in the evening with the perfect drink in hand.

Customer feedback consistently highlights the combination of generous portion sizes, delicious food, and friendly service. Dawn Mooney praises the attentive waitstaff and particularly loves the wings, calling them "sweet garlic parm wings or buffalo wings!!!" Krista echoes these sentiments, noting the "very large portions" and "delicious" dishes like the portabella mushroom sticks and jalapeño burger. Tim Creek, a seasoned traveler, was "genuinely surprised" by the quality and warmth of this classic bar, calling it "just the kind of place you would want to stop in for a great meal."

While some visitors have noted occasional service slowdowns, the overall consensus echoes a welcoming vibe and satisfying dining experience, with staff who keep the atmosphere relaxed and friendly. Whether you’re a local or just passing through Mt Olive, Tilleys Tavern offers a hearty, memorable meal in a setting that feels like a second home.

For a taste of genuine small-town hospitality paired with comforting American bar & grill favorites, Tilleys Tavern should earn a top spot on your dining itinerary.

Contact: 303 E Main St, Mt Olive, IL 62069 | Phone: +1 217-999-2279